Storm Shelter
Holds a broad U.S. stock fund above its 200-day price average. Below it, switches to a fund of consumer staples such as food and household goods.
| Risk | Holding time | For players who want |
|---|---|---|
| Medium | Months to Years | A rule for switching stock funds |
How it works
SPY's price trend chooses between two stock funds.
Above the average SPY tracks the S&P 500, a group of large U.S. companies. When SPY's closing price is above its 200-day average, the strategy holds SPY.
Below the average When SPY closes below its average, the strategy switches to XLP. This fund holds consumer-staples companies, which sell goods such as food and household products. XLP can still lose money.
Targets one fund at a time. Checks each trading close. Switches fill at the next trading open. The rule does not check XLP's own price trend.
Rules at a glance
- Eligible assets
- Fixed list: SPY, XLP.
- Schedule
- Checks its rule at every trading close.
- Money split
- All the money in one asset.
- Automatic loss limit
- None.
| Detail | What it means |
|---|---|
| Holds | SPY or XLP, one stock fund at a time |
| Style | Switches funds using SPY's price trend |
| Trade timing | Checks each trading close; switches at the next open |
| Money split | Targets 100% in the selected fund |
| Risk | Medium |
| Automatic loss limit | None; a weaker SPY trend selects XLP |
What to watch out for
- Both choices are stock funds. XLP can fall alongside SPY. Switching to consumer staples does not guarantee a smaller loss.
- XLP concentrates the money in one sector. The rule can buy or keep XLP while its own price is falling.
- Switches can reverse. When SPY stays near its average, repeated changes can sell one fund and buy the other at unfavorable prices.
Source
Uses the S&P 500 fund's price trend to switch between broad U.S. stocks and consumer staples.
Full rulebook
1. Strategy overview
- Name: Storm Shelter
- Goal: Target SPY when SPY closes above its 200-day average, and XLP when it closes below.
- Idea: Respond to a weaker broad-market trend by changing the stock fund held.
2. Investments it can hold
- SPY: SPDR S&P 500 ETF Trust, a fund of large U.S. companies
- XLP: Consumer Staples Select Sector SPDR Fund, a fund of consumer-staples companies
- An ETF is a fund that trades on an exchange like a stock.
- The choice is fixed to these two funds.
3. Data and schedule
- Data: SPY's daily closing prices; no company financial data
- History needed: 200 trading days
- Check: after every trading day's close
- Trades: when the target changes, at the next trading day's open
4. When it buys
- Calculate the simple average of SPY's last 200 closing prices, including today.
- Above that average, target SPY. Below it, target XLP.
- On an exact tie, keep SPY if it is already held. Otherwise target XLP, including when starting with neither fund.
- When a switch is needed, sell the current fund and buy the target at the next trading day's open.
- If SPY's close or average is unavailable, keep whichever fund is held. If neither is held, keep cash.
- Maximum holdings: one fund
- When you start: apply the same rule to that day's close and fill any purchase at the next trading open.
5. When it sells
- Sell a fund when the daily rule selects the other fund.
- The normal price rule switches between SPY and XLP. It does not select cash during a market fall.
- Time limit: none
6. How it divides the money
- Target: 100% in the selected fund
- Cash: rounding leftovers and dividend cash can remain between switches. There is no scheduled reset to invest them while the target stays the same.
- Stop loss: none. A decline in either holding does not trigger a separate percentage-loss sale.
- Take profit: none
7. Moon's notes
- Every signal uses SPY's price and average. XLP's own trend does not affect selection.
- The target describes the intended allocation. Cash can still exist before the first purchase, from missing data, rounding or dividends.
- Dividends on shares held at the previous close enter cash on the ex-dividend date. This is the first day a new buyer no longer qualifies for that dividend, and it can be earlier than payment day.