Skip to content
Back to strategies

Defensive Duo

Splits money equally between a consumer-staples stock fund and a healthcare stock fund. Holds both through market changes and resets the mix each year.

Backtest this strategyFree account required
RiskHolding timeFor players who want
LowYearsStocks focused on everyday needs

How it works

Two funds focus on companies that sell everyday goods and healthcare.

What it buys XLP holds consumer-staples companies, such as makers of food and household goods. XLV holds healthcare companies. A sector fund groups companies in one part of the economy.

What changes each year The strategy targets half the money in each fund. Each January, it resets that split by selling amounts above target and buying amounts below it. Both funds stay in the mix.

Targets 50% XLP and 50% XLV. Resets once a year. It keeps holding during market falls.

Rules at a glance

Eligible assets
Fixed list: XLP, XLV.
Schedule
Rechecks and resets at each year-end.
Money split
Fixed target percentages.
Automatic loss limit
None.
DetailWhat it means
HoldsXLP and XLV; two U.S. stock-sector funds
StyleA fixed mix of consumer staples and healthcare
Trade timingYearly, at the first trading open of January
Money split50% consumer staples / 50% healthcare
RiskLow
Automatic loss limitNone

What to watch out for

  • Both funds hold stocks. The name does not promise smaller losses. There is no bond target or automatic switch to cash.
  • Two sectors leave much of the market out. The strategy can trail when other sectors lead, and it does not add them.
  • A yearly reset can be a long wait. A struggling sector stays in the portfolio between resets. The next reset can buy more of it.

Source

Uses an equal mix of consumer-staples and healthcare sector funds.

Full rulebook

1. Strategy overview

  • Name: Defensive Duo
  • Goal: Hold 50% XLP and 50% XLV. Reset the mix once a year.
  • Idea: Keep equal target weights in consumer-staples and healthcare stocks without a market-timing rule.

2. Investments it can hold

  • XLP: Consumer Staples Select Sector SPDR, target 50%
  • XLV: Health Care Select Sector SPDR, target 50%
  • An ETF is a fund that trades on an exchange like a stock.
  • The fund list and target shares of the portfolio are fixed. You do not choose individual stocks or change the mix.

3. Data and schedule

  • Company financial data: none
  • History needed: no lookback, or zero trading days. The funds still need price data for the dates in the test.
  • First signal: the close on the day you start
  • Reset signal: the final trading close of December
  • Scheduled trades: the first trading open of January, using the previous trading day's signal
  • No price threshold, ranking or trend check changes the target mix.

4. When it buys

When you start the strategy, and at each yearly reset:

  1. Set the target percentages for every fund on the list.
  2. At the next trading open, calculate total portfolio value using the opening prices, including available cash.
  3. Multiply that value by each fund's target percentage to find its target value.
  4. Sell amounts above their targets, then buy amounts below them at that open.
  • Targets: 50% XLP and 50% XLV
  • Maximum holdings: 2 funds
  • Share rounding can leave cash. A fund already at its target share count needs no trade.

5. When it sells

  • At each yearly reset, trim funds above their target values. The rule keeps the same fund list.
  • Between resets, a price fall does not trigger a sale or a switch to cash.
  • End the strategy to sell its holdings.
  • Time limit: none

6. How it divides the money

  • Targets: 50% XLP and 50% XLV
  • Cash: rounding leftovers and fund distributions wait in cash until the next yearly reset, when they can buy more fund shares.
  • Actual weights can drift as prices change.
  • Stop loss: none. There is no separate sell rule triggered by a percentage loss.
  • Take profit: none. The scheduled reset can trim a fund that has grown above its target.

7. Moon's notes

  • This is a stock portfolio concentrated in two sectors. Utilities and other sectors are not part of its fixed list.
  • The strategy does not check demand, company profits or economic forecasts before holding either fund.
  • A distribution is a cash payment from a fund. Distributions on shares held at the previous close enter strategy cash on the ex-dividend date, when a new buyer no longer qualifies for that payment. This can be earlier than the payment date.