Market Leaders backtest worksheet answer key
For facilitators. This page contains the worked answers.
This key uses the saved Market Leaders report captured on 12 November 2026. Its actual test period is 4 October 2022 to 11 November 2026. The figures below use the companion article's rounded values. A report opened later may differ.
1. Make a prediction before viewing results
Grade the reason and the evidence the student would use to question it. Do not grade a prediction by whether it guessed the final result.
One possible prediction is: "I expect Market Leaders to finish ahead of the S&P 500 benchmark because it selects stocks with strong earlier price gains. I would question this if its total return finished below the benchmark over the same period."
A student can also predict underperformance and give a reason based on the rules. For example, the strategy skips the latest 21 trading days when it ranks stocks. A selected stock may have fallen during that skipped period.
Keep the student's original prediction. Do not rewrite it after seeing the result.
2. Record the strategy
The strategy is Market Leaders. A complete description should cover these rules:
- It chooses eligible U.S. common stocks with a signal-date closing price of at least $5. Each needs at least $50 million in average daily dollar trading volume over the trailing 63 trading days.
- It compares the closing price 21 trading days earlier with the closing price 252 trading days earlier. Only positive gains qualify.
- It ranks those gains and selects up to 20 stocks. Alphabetical ticker order breaks ties. Each target slot receives 5% of the strategy's capital. Empty slots remain cash.
- It first selects holdings using the starting day's close. It then checks holdings at the last trading-day close of each month. Orders fill at the next trading open.
At a monthly check, it sells holdings outside the new qualifying top 20. It also resets retained holdings toward their 5% targets. A holding may drop out because another stock outranks it or it no longer qualifies.
The strategy has no stop loss, take-profit rule, or fixed holding-period exit. A price decline during the month does not itself trigger a sale.
3. Identify the report
For the companion article's example, select "The article's dated example." The source is a prepared Market Leaders report, not a new personal simulation.
| Worksheet field | Answer for the dated example |
|---|---|
| Report source | The dated Market Leaders teaching example |
| Archived capture | 12 November 2026 at 13:03:59 UTC |
| Requested start date in the archived data | 11 November 2021 |
| Actual report start date | 4 October 2022 |
| Actual report end date | 11 November 2026 |
Students should record when they copied their results, separate from the archived capture date. If they opened a report in TickerTown, they should record that report's source, dates, and values.
The report does not cover the full requested period. It does not explain why the period is shorter. "Not shown" is acceptable for a requested start date the student cannot see.
4. Copy the results and compare
| Measure | Answer using the rounded example |
|---|---|
| Total return | +161.1% |
| Annualized return | +26.3% per year |
| S&P 500 return (same period) | +111.8% |
| Max drawdown | -61.0% |
| Number of trades | 1,327 |
| Win rate | 56% |
The comparison is 161.1% minus 111.8% = 49.3 percentage points. Market Leaders finishes ahead of the benchmark in this simulation.
The archived values have more precision: +161.09% and +111.75%. Their difference is 49.34 percentage points. Accept either calculation when the student uses one level of precision throughout.
The annualized return expresses the full-period growth as an equivalent compounded yearly rate. It does not mean the account gained 26.3% in every year.
Number of trades counts individual simulated buy or sell fills, including rebalance adjustments. Win rate measures positive complete months. The archived count is 27 out of 48, or 56.25%, which rounds to 56%.
The drawdown means the simulated daily-close account value lost about 61% from a peak before it reached a later low. The archived chart points put that peak on 4 June 2026 and the low on 5 November 2026.
On the chart's starting value of $100, those values are $591.7575 and $231.0022. The decline is about 60.96% of the peak. These dates come from the archived chart points; the summary metric alone does not give them. The decline measures a loss from the peak, not a 61% loss of the original $100.
5. Decide what the evidence supports
One supported finding is: "From 4 October 2022 to 11 November 2026, Market Leaders returned 161.1% in the simulation. The benchmark returned 111.8%. The difference was 49.3 percentage points."
That supports a prediction of a higher final return for this period. The drawdown complicates the conclusion. A higher ending value came with a fall of about 61% from an earlier peak.
One unsupported claim is: "Market Leaders will beat the S&P 500 over the next four years." This report measures one past simulated period. It cannot establish a future result.
Accept a limitation when the student explains its effect. For example: "This is one period. A different market period could change the ranking, so I cannot treat this result as a general rule."
Another valid limitation concerns execution. The captured report does not list all trading-cost assumptions. The student should check commissions, spreads, slippage and taxes before comparing the result with real trading. Costs and execution can change the outcome.
One useful next question is: "Would the result change over a different period?" Evidence would require another report with known start and end dates and the same rules and benchmark.
Credit other questions when the student names the evidence they would need.
6. Optional follow up observation
There is no preset answer. Complete this section only for an existing active paper-money strategy after TickerTown processes a later market session.
Students should record the strategy name, the date they checked, and the processed session date. Their observations must come from the account. An unchanged value or no trade is a valid observation if that is what the account shows.
A value change can come from prices without a trade. Market Leaders refreshes its selection monthly, so checking it daily does not imply daily changes to its holdings. Do not invent a trade or a gain to complete the exercise.